Individuals vote at a polling station in Pasadena, Calif., on Nov. 4, 2025.
Mario Tama/Getty Pictures
conceal caption
toggle caption
Mario Tama/Getty Pictures
A Republican voting overhaul is again on Capitol Hill — with an added photograph identification provision and an altered title — as President Trump seeks to upend elections in a midterm yr. Opponents say the laws would disenfranchise tens of millions of voters.
The Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act — now dubbed the SAVE America Act — narrowly handed the U.S. Home final week, with all Republicans and one Democrat backing the invoice.
Its approval took place 10 months after Home Republicans final handed the SAVE Act.
The measure, which might rework voter registration and voting throughout the nation, faces persistent hurdles within the GOP-led Senate resulting from Democratic disapproval and the 60-vote threshold to clear the legislative filibuster. Some Republicans have referred to as for maneuvering across the filibuster to cross the laws, however GOP management has been cool to the thought.
The overhaul would require eligible voters to supply proof of citizenship — like a legitimate U.S. passport, or a start certificates plus legitimate photograph identification — when registering to vote. The brand new iteration provides a requirement that voters additionally present photograph ID when casting their poll.
“This invoice takes a powerful piece of laws, the SAVE Act, and makes it even stronger within the SAVE America Act,” Rep. Bryan Steil, R-Wis., chair of the Committee on Home Administration, mentioned in ready remarks on Capitol Hill final week.
It is already unlawful for non-U.S. residents to vote in federal elections, and confirmed situations of fraud — together with by noncitizens — are vanishingly uncommon.
However Steil and different Republicans say present legislation, which requires sworn attestation of citizenship underneath penalty of perjury, will not be robust sufficient, and documentary proof is required.
U.S. Rep. Bryan Steil, R-Wis., speaks throughout a Home Guidelines Committee assembly in regards to the SAVE America Act on Feb. 10. At proper is Rep. Joe Morelle, D-N.Y.
Samuel Corum/Getty Pictures
conceal caption
toggle caption
Samuel Corum/Getty Pictures
Some states already take steps to confirm citizenship for newly registered voters. And three dozen states additionally require voters to point out an ID to solid a poll, with some mandating it’s a photograph ID, whereas others enable extra choices, reminiscent of a financial institution assertion.
Democrats and voting rights advocates say the brand new SAVE Act is even worse than the prior iteration, and that the laws’s two principal identification necessities would make voting notably tougher for tens of tens of millions of People who do not have quick access to vital private documentation. About half of People did not have a passport as of 2023, as an illustration.
The measure’s provisions would take impact instantly, a prospect that opponents see as inserting an unfair burden on voters and election officers proper earlier than tens of millions are set to solid midterm ballots, and with out additional funding. These election officers would additionally face legal penalties, together with imprisonment, for registering voters with out proof of citizenship.
The invoice’s prospects seem slim within the Senate, at the same time as Trump and members of his administration ramp up public messaging in favor of the overhaul — typically by pointing to polling that reveals 8 in 10 People help the proof-of-citizenship and photograph ID provisions.
Trump tried to overturn his 2020 election loss and has lengthy railed baselessly about corrupt elections, and most of the president’s opponents see the push for the SAVE invoice as intertwined along with his efforts to boost doubts about voting and intervene with this yr’s midterms.
Michael Waldman, head of the Brennan Middle of Justice, which advocates for expanded voting entry, described the measure as “Trump’s energy seize in legislative garb.”
Trump raised alarms by suggesting just lately that Republicans ought to “nationalize” elections, and final week he teased a brand new govt order, writing on social media: “There might be Voter I.D. for the Midterm Elections, whether or not accredited by Congress or not!”
The U.S. Structure grants states and Congress management over election guidelines, and a 2025 govt order from Trump, which sought to require proof of citizenship for voter registration, has been halted by federal judges who say the order’s provisions exceed a president’s authority.
Listed here are 4 new gadgets within the new SAVE Act:
1. The photograph ID provision solely lists legitimate U.S. passports, driver’s licenses, state IDs, navy IDs and tribal IDs as acceptable. Voters who don’t current one should vote provisionally and return in three days with an ID, or signal an affidavit that claims they’ve “a non secular objection to being photographed.”
Notably, individuals who do not vote in particular person should additionally submit a replica of a legitimate photograph ID.
2. The laws consists of new pointers for title discrepancies in proof-of-citizenship paperwork. That features, per the invoice, “an affidavit signed by the applicant testifying that the title on the documentation is a earlier title of the applicant.”
This nods at one criticism of the measure, which is that tens of tens of millions of girls modified their title after getting married, and so their present names do not match their start certificates.
3. The measure gives exemptions for absent service members and their households.
4. The invoice requires every state to submit its voter checklist to the Division of Homeland Safety for comparability with the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) system.
The Trump administration has overhauled SAVE, turning it right into a de facto nationwide citizenship system. Regardless of privateness and information accuracy considerations, a variety of states have eagerly used the brand new SAVE software to attempt to determine and take away noncitizens on their voter rolls. However SAVE has erroneously flagged U.S. residents too.
